How to Reset Expectations with Your Team (Without Sounding Like a Drill Sergeant)

Resetting expectations can feel… tricky. You want your team to understand what’s expected of them, hit goals, and improve performance. But you also want to avoid sounding like a drill sergeant handing out marching orders.

Good news: it’s possible. With the right approach, you can reset expectations in a way that’s clear, motivating, and even builds trust — not fear.

Here’s your guide for doing it right.

Step 1: Start With Yourself (Check Your Own Expectations)

Before you call a team meeting or send a long email, pause and make sure your expectations are crystal clear in your own mind.

Ask yourself:

• Are these expectations realistic?

• Are they consistent with company values and culture?

• Are they achievable with the current resources, tools, and workload?

  
  

Nothing sabotages a reset faster than holding your team accountable to standards you haven’t fully clarified for yourself.

Pro tip: Write down your expectations for each role or team. Seeing it on paper helps you communicate more clearly.

Step 2: Focus on Behaviors, Not Personalities

When resetting expectations, your goal is to influence what people do, not who they are. Avoid statements like “You’re not organized” or “You’re lazy.” Instead, focus on actionable behaviors:

• “We need reports submitted by Friday at 5 PM.”

• “Meetings should have a clear agenda shared 24 hours in advance.”

• “Everyone should update the project tracker daily.”

Behavioral language makes feedback clear, actionable, and non-personal — reducing defensiveness and increasing compliance.

Step 3: Use the Sandwich Method (Feedback With a Smile)

Here’s a classic but effective tool for delivering expectations: the sandwich.

1. Start with a positive or acknowledgment – show you value the person or their work.

   Example: “I really appreciate how committed you are to hitting deadlines.”

2. Reset the expectation – clearly describe the behavior you need to see.

   Example: “Moving forward, I need weekly updates on your projects by Monday morning so the team can plan accordingly.”

3. Close on encouragement or support – offer help or show confidence in their ability.

   Example: “I know you can handle this, and I’m happy to give you tools to make it easier.”

   
   

This method keeps the tone professional and motivating — no marching orders required.

Step 4: Make It a Conversation, Not a Lecture

Resetting expectations shouldn’t feel like a top-down decree. Give your team a chance to share perspective:

• Ask, “What obstacles are preventing this goal from being reached?”

• Invite ideas on how the process could be improved.

• Clarify misunderstandings about priorities or deadlines.

  
  

This approach turns the reset into a collaborative process. Your team is more likely to buy in when they feel heard — and you might uncover barriers you hadn’t noticed.

Step 5: Communicate Expectations Clearly and Consistently

Clarity is your best friend. Ambiguous expectations are the #1 reason resets fail.

• Use multiple formats: Email, Slack, shared docs, or team meetings.

• Repeat the key points: Reinforcement ensures everyone remembers.

• Document it: A shared expectations sheet keeps everyone on the same page.

  
  

Consistency also matters: follow through when expectations are not met. If you reset one week and ignore it the next, your team will tune out future guidance.

Step 6: Tie Expectations to Outcomes and Impact

Instead of just giving instructions, explain why expectations matter. People perform better when they understand how their work affects the team or company.

Examples:

• “Submitting reports on time helps the marketing team launch campaigns on schedule.”

• “Updating the project tracker ensures leadership can identify roadblocks before they become problems.”

When expectations are linked to purpose, compliance feels meaningful — not punitive.

Step 7: Celebrate Small Wins

Resetting expectations isn’t just about correcting course — it’s about reinforcing good behavior.

• Recognize improvements publicly (if the person is comfortable).

• Send a quick note acknowledging progress: “Thanks for getting reports in on time this week — it’s really helping the team!”

• Celebrate milestones when a process is fully adopted.

This positive reinforcement encourages ongoing alignment without feeling authoritarian.

Step 8: Set a Follow-Up Plan

Resetting expectations is rarely a one-and-done conversation. Schedule check-ins to:

• Review progress

• Clarify questions

• Adjust if needed

Check-ins can be brief: 15–20 minutes to see how the new rhythm is going. This keeps the team accountable while showing support.

Step 9: Use Tools to Make It Easier

Small businesses often lack formal HR infrastructure, so resetting expectations can be messy. A few tools can help:

• Shared Docs: Keep expectations and deadlines in a Google Sheet or Teams document.

• Project Management Software: Trello, Asana, or ClickUp can provide clear visibility.

• HR Consulting Support: Fractional HR services (like Lynn HR Consulting’s Real Time HR) can help craft clear expectations, communication templates, or even run reset meetings for you.

The right tools reduce confusion, increase transparency, and make expectations stick.

Step 10: Keep Your Tone Playful (Yes, Really)

Who says HR has to be boring? Resetting expectations doesn’t have to feel like a drill sergeant yelling orders. Inject a little personality and warmth:

• Use humor when appropriate: “Let’s all try to hit these deadlines — or I might start bribing people with coffee!”

• Celebrate progress in creative ways: shout-outs in Slack, small team rewards, or quirky acknowledgments.

• Keep communications human, not robotic.

A professional yet playful tone builds trust and makes people more receptive — and you’ll get better results.

Sample Reset Conversation

Here’s what a practical reset conversation might look like:

Manager: “I want to talk about our weekly reports. I really appreciate how hard everyone is working. Lately, we’ve had some delays in submitting updates, which slows down our project planning. Going forward, I’d like everyone to submit updates by 5 PM on Friday. Does anyone see any obstacles to that? How can I help make this happen?”

Team member: “I’ve been juggling multiple projects; it’s sometimes hard to finish everything.”

Manager: “Thanks for sharing! Let’s see if we can shift priorities or adjust workloads. I know we can get these updates in on time — and I’ll check in with each of you to support it.”

Notice how this is clear, non-punitive, and collaborative — not a military-style lecture.

Key Takeaways: Reset Expectations Without the Drill Sergeant

Principle	Action
Start with yourself	Make sure your expectations are realistic and clear
Focus on behaviors	Describe what you need, not who someone is
Sandwich your feedback	Positive → Expectation → Support
Make it a conversation	Invite dialogue and collaboration
Communicate clearly	Multiple formats, repeated, documented
Tie to impact	Show why the expectations matter
Celebrate wins	Recognize improvement and progress
Follow up	Schedule check-ins to maintain alignment
Use tools	Docs, project software, HR support
Keep it playful	Humor and warmth make the message stick

Final Thoughts

Resetting expectations is less about telling people what to do and more about creating clarity, alignment, and mutual accountability. Done well, it strengthens trust, boosts performance, and keeps your small business running smoothly.

2026 is the perfect year to reset expectations in a professional yet playful way — so your team knows what success looks like without anyone needing a whistle, clipboard, or drill sergeant hat.

__________________________________________________________________________________

Lynn HR Consulting is a female-owned and operated business that provides a wide variety of Human Resources and Payroll services at an affordable cost. We focus on helping small to midsize businesses thrive by creating great workplaces while also providing strategic projects and filling interim roles for larger corporations. Contact us today to learn how we can support your organization’s growth and success.