The Meeting Test: If This Meeting Were Optional, Would Anyone Attend?
- Ariana Attigliato
- 2 days ago
- 5 min read
Let's start with a potentially uncomfortable question. Imagine you sent a calendar invite for your next team meeting. But instead of marking it as required, you made it completely optional.
No pressure.
No consequences.
No follow-up questions.
Just a simple note:
"Attend if you think it'll be valuable."
Now be honest.
How many people would show up?
If that question makes you nervous, you're not alone. Meetings have become one of the biggest workplace frustrations across industries. Employees joke about them. Leaders complain about them. Entire internet memes have been built around them. Yet somehow, calendars remain packed.
At Lynn HR Consulting, we've found that meetings are often a symptom of a larger issue—not the issue itself. When meetings become excessive, repetitive, or unproductive, they usually point to deeper challenges involving communication, accountability, decision-making, or leadership.
The good news?
A few small changes can dramatically improve meeting effectiveness, employee engagement, and workplace productivity.
So before scheduling another recurring meeting, let's put it through a simple test:
Would anyone attend if they didn't have to?
Why Employees Hate Meetings
Let's clear something up. Employees don't hate all meetings. They hate bad meetings.
The kind that:
Could have been an email
Have no agenda
Start late
End late
Solve nothing
Include people who don't need to be there
Repeat information everyone already knows
Most employees don't mind spending time on conversations that help them succeed. What they dislike is spending time on conversations that feel pointless.
And honestly? They're not wrong.
The Hidden Cost of Bad Meetings
When leaders think about meetings, they often focus on the time spent in the room. But the true cost is much larger.
Consider a one-hour meeting with ten employees.
That's not a one-hour meeting.
That's a ten-hour meeting.
Now add:
Preparation time
Follow-up conversations
Context switching
Lost focus
Suddenly, that simple meeting may have consumed an entire day of productivity across the organization.
That's why effective meetings aren't just a communication issue. They're a business issue.
The Optional Meeting Test
Before scheduling any meeting, ask yourself:
If attendance were optional:
Would employees see value in showing up?
Would they leave with useful information?
Would decisions be made?
Would work move forward?
If the answer is no, reconsider the meeting. Not every conversation needs a conference room. Sometimes the best meeting is the one that never happens.
Sign 1: Nobody Knows Why They're There
Have you ever joined a meeting and immediately wondered:
"Why am I here?"
Your employees have too.
One of the biggest meeting mistakes is inviting people simply because it feels safer than excluding them.
The result?
Rooms full of people who aren't contributing, learning, or making decisions.
Better Approach
Ask:
Who needs information?
Who makes decisions?
Who contributes expertise?
Invite those people.
Leave everyone else alone.
Their inbox already has enough going on.
Sign 2: There Is No Clear Agenda
Imagine showing up for a road trip and the driver says:
"We'll figure out where we're going when we get there."
You'd probably be concerned. Yet many meetings operate exactly this way.
Without an agenda:
Conversations wander
Priorities get lost
Decisions take longer
Meetings run over
Better Approach
Every meeting should answer three questions:
Why are we meeting?
What decisions need to be made?
What should happen afterward?
If those answers aren't clear, neither is the meeting.
Sign 3: The Same Topics Keep Coming Back
If you've discussed the same issue three meetings in a row, the problem isn't the meeting. The problem is execution.
Many teams confuse discussing work with doing work. Conversation feels productive. Action creates results.
Better Approach
End every meeting with:
Clear ownership
Specific deadlines
Defined next steps
Otherwise, you'll simply revisit the same discussion next week.
Sign 4: Leadership Does Most of the Talking
This is a surprisingly common issue.
Leaders spend the entire meeting:
Providing updates
Sharing information
Answering questions
Meanwhile, employees sit quietly.
At that point, you're not having a meeting. You're giving a presentation. And presentations often don't require everyone to stop working simultaneously.
Better Approach
Create opportunities for discussion:
Ask questions
Invite ideas
Encourage problem-solving
Request feedback
The best meetings feel like collaboration—not lectures.
Sign 5: Decisions Never Get Made
Employees become frustrated when meetings generate endless discussion but no action.
Eventually, they start wondering:
"Why are we talking about this again?"
Decision paralysis kills engagement.
People want clarity.
They want direction.
They want movement.
Better Approach
Every meeting should produce one of three outcomes:
A decision
A plan
A next step
If none of those happen, reconsider the purpose of the meeting.
The Back-to-School Meeting Audit
As we continue our August Back-to-School theme, consider this your meeting report card.
Give yourself one point for every "yes."
Do all recurring meetings still have a purpose?
Does every meeting have an agenda?
Do attendees know why they're invited?
Are action items clearly assigned?
Do meetings start and end on time?
Are decisions being made?
Do employees actively participate?
Could some meetings be emails?
Are managers modeling good meeting habits?
Would employees choose to attend?
8–10 Points: Honor Roll
Your meetings are likely creating value.
Keep it up.
5–7 Points: Needs Improvement
Some adjustments could significantly improve productivity.
0–4 Points: Parent-Teacher Conference Needed
Let's talk.
How Great Meetings Improve Employee Engagement
When meetings are effective, employees feel:
Informed
Included
Respected
Connected to goals
When meetings are ineffective, employees feel:
Frustrated
Distracted
Unproductive
Disengaged
That's why meeting quality directly impacts employee engagement and workplace culture. People notice how leaders value their time.
Three Simple Changes You Can Make This Week
1. End Recurring Meetings That No Longer Serve a Purpose
Just because a meeting has existed for two years doesn't mean it should continue.
Give every recurring meeting a purpose review.
2. Cut Meeting Time in Half
Many 60-minute meetings could be 30.
Many 30-minute meetings could be 15.
Constraints create focus.
3. End With Action
Before anyone leaves, ask:
Who owns this?
What's the deadline?
What's next?
Simple.
Powerful.
Effective.
The Lynn HR Perspective
One of the most overlooked aspects of workplace culture is how organizations use people's time. Every meeting sends a message.
It communicates:
What leadership values
How decisions are made
Whether employee time is respected
How accountability works
The healthiest organizations don't have fewer conversations. They have better ones. They create meetings that move work forward instead of slowing it down. And they understand that employee engagement isn't built by filling calendars.
It's built by making every interaction meaningful.
Final Thoughts
The next time you're about to send a meeting invite, pause for a moment.
Ask yourself:
If attendance were optional, would anyone come?
If the answer is yes, you're probably creating value.
If the answer is no, there may be a better way.
Because great meetings don't happen because people are required to attend. They happen because people believe their time will be well spent. And in today's workplace, that's one of the best grades a leader can earn.
At Lynn HR Consulting, we help businesses improve communication, employee engagement, leadership effectiveness, and workplace productivity through practical HR strategies that make work—and meetings—better for everyone.
__________________________________________________________________________________
Lynn HR Consulting is a female-owned and operated business that provides a wide variety of Human Resources and Payroll services at an affordable cost. We focus on helping small to midsize businesses thrive by creating great workplaces while also providing strategic projects and filling interim roles for larger corporations. Contact us today to learn how we can support your organization’s growth and success.
Comments